When you first heard of cloth diapering, probably what popped into mind was the basic prefold, magically wrapped around the baby's bottom, secured with pins, and waterproofed by plastic-y pull-up pants. Right? That was the case for me at least. While some parents do still use this style for the greatest cost savings, as you will see from the options below, this is no longer the only (or preferred by the majority of cloth diaperers) style available.
So how does it work, generally? It's pretty simple, really. You have an absorbent material(s) + a waterproof material + possibly a soft-to-the-skin/moisture-wicking material in just about every cloth diaper. The overwhelming part to the person considering making the switch is how this plays out. This is due to the sheer volume of options. I will try to walk you through them, so bear with me.
All-in-one (AIO)
This type of diaper is just as the name suggests: the absorbent part and the waterproof part are all in one, making for a very user-friendly diaper, especially for dads and supplemental caregivers (read: grandparents, babysitters and daycare providers).
Pros: No assembly required, just put on baby and go. No breakdown of parts required for washing, just toss in laundry pail and go.
Cons: Can by pricier than other options. Once diaper is wet or dirty, the whole thing goes into the diaper pail (minus solid poo). Can take much longer to dry due to minimal surface area exposed to the drying heat source. Can retain smells due to less surface area exposed to washing and rinsing water, possibly leading to a greater chance for detergent build-up (which traps stinkies).
Pocket
This type of diaper, once assembled, functions as an AIO. Some people hate stuffing the diaper, others don't mind it and treat it like any other laundry--prep while watching TV, sipping a hot beverage, listening to some relaxing tunes, etc. It offers the same convenience for diaper-changers if pre-stuffed with the absorbent material before a new dipe is needed.
Pros: Minimal assembly required. Retains odors less and dries faster than AIOs because the absorbent stuffing has all sides exposed in the laundry cycle. Typically less costly than AIOs.
Cons: Once diaper is wet or dirty, the whole thing goes into the diaper pail (minus solid poo). Some disassembly recommended before tossing into diaper pail.
All-in-two (AI2)
This type typically (more and more styles becoming available) keeps the absorbent layer separate from the waterproof layer, although there are some that don't (in those cases there is a snap-in "soaker" to add extra absorbency to the outer part).
Pros: May be less costly than pockets. Retains odors less and dries faster than AIOs, but about as well as pocket stuffing. The outer part can typically be reused through several diaper changes, while the absorbent part gets tossed into the pail (though in some cases poo gets on the outer), which can mean less laundry volume per load. Some styles offer the option for disposable (read: flushable, compostable, or otherwise biodegradable) inserts.
Cons: Some assembly required. Absorbent inserts may shift once in place or while putting on a wiggly baby. Absorbent inserts should have a top layer that is gentle on baby's skin, whereas pocket stuffing does not need this as the inner pocket lining serves this function. If an option, disposable inserts are more costly per insert than regular disposable diapers per diaper.
OK, now that we've covered the basic styles, there is a bit more you should know. We can discuss good materials for absorbency or moisture-wicking later, but first--the design of the absorbent material. This section applies only to the AI2 category.
Prefolds
A prefold is a rectangular piece of cloth, usually cotton, with extra fabric sewn into the middle. They can be particularly useful on newborns as they are quite inexpensive, easy to wash/dry, and not too bulk on tiny bottoms; and considering the amount of newborn diaper changes needed, this is a decent starter option. But let the record show that I would still advocate for a different fastening device than pins: it's called a Snappi and looks a bit like a three-headed, plastic version of those metal things used to secure an Ace bandage :o). Also, I would recommend a more breathable waterproof layer than plastic pants. A prefold, either folded into thirds on itself (long and skinny) or fanned out around the baby's fanny and pinned or Snappi'd, can work just as well as other options under a breathable cover such as those found in the AI2 group. And while you certainly can use the inexpensive prefold diapers by Gerber there are other, more absorbent, slightly less inexpensive prefolds out there.
Pros: Really inexpensive. Wash well, dry well. Can be folded into thirds and used as pocket stuffing or an insert for an AI2/cover. Can be used as a burp rag or cleaning cloth without looking, well, like you're cleaning with a diaper--awkward!
Cons: Assembly required and can be tricky if using pins or Snappi, but only slightly more assembly required if tri-folded into a cover or pocket. May need bigger sizes as the baby grows if this is the main type of diaper in one's stash.
Flat diapers
These are made of the same materials as prefolds, but are only one layer of fabric and shaped as a square (almost). When folded (and folded and folded) these can function the same as a prefold.
Pros: The most inexpensive option available (i.e. I bought 12 for $13.50 and that might have included shipping, vs $13.50 for one relatively inexpensive pocket diaper). Wash well, dry very well. No problems with smells or stains unless there is something wrong with your wash routine. :o) Can be used as a burp rag, changing table cover, thin blanket, nursing cover, cleaning cloth, etc etc etc. Very versatile.
Cons: Lots of assembly required.
Fitteds
These are made from various absorbent materials--one type or a combo of types of fabric--and are shaped like a diaper that's ready to go, but lacks the waterproof layer. They typically have some kind of fastening device: snaps, hook-and-loop, pins/Snappi. Worn under a waterproof cover unless you have plastic-covered furniture in your home :o).
Pros: Minimal assembly required. Dry faster than most AIOs, about the same as most inserts (pockets or AI2s), but likely not as fast as prefolds. May contain messes (read: non-solid-food-eating baby poo) better than folded prefolds or flats, allowing you to have a better chance of reusing the waterproof cover for more diaper changes.
Cons: Still need a waterproof cover, so it can feel like you're putting two diapers on the baby. Pricier than prefolds, flats, and inserts.
Contour diapers
These are similar to a fitted diaper, only with less structure to them. They typically do not come with a fastening device and may be difficult to find in a retail store near you. Warn under a waterproof cover.
Pros: Less costly than fitteds. Dry faster than most AIOs, about the same as most inserts (pockets or AI2s), but likely not as fast as prefolds.
Cons: Some assembly required. May not contain messes as well as fitteds, but possibly better than folded prefolds or flats. Still need a waterproof cover.
Absorbent inserts
These are typically shaped like a rounded rectangle or an hourglass. Most are made of several layers of absorbent material (some natural, some man-made, some combined) sewn together. Some have a soft layer on top nearest baby's skin. Some have a stay-dry layer to wick moisture away from baby's skin so they don't feel wet (good for nighttime, bad for potty-training). They simply lie inside a waterproof cover that may or may not have snaps or small pockets to help hold them in place. They can also be used as pocket stuffing or extra absorbency layers in AIOs.
Pros: Less assembly required than prefolds. No pins or Snappi needed. Wide variety available. Can be used with many different diapering systems.
Cons: More costly than prefolds or flats. Take longer to dry than prefolds or flats. If you end up with a lot of styles in your stash it can be difficult to remember which style goes with which diaper, or if one type has a fabric appropriate for baby's skin or stay-dry, etc. Those made of man-made materials can retain odors more than natural fibers.
(Wow. I'm feeling a bit overwhelmed and I already use cloth! Just breathe.)
Anyway, as you can imagine, there are debates as to which style is better than another, but it really boils down to what your lifestyle is, how much time you have available to spend diapering your child(ren), how much money you have available to spend on start-up and/or later costs, who will be doing the most diaper changes, etc. Many retailers offer trial packages so you can try a few different kinds of diapers and return whatever doesn't work for you! That's a great option for someone with an open mind and inquisitive nature. For those of you like myself who need more predictability, I can direct you to some outside sites that provide comprehensive diaper reviews if need be. As for me and my stash? We have several AI2s--covers + various types of inserts (including some flushable ones) or folded flats, a couple of pocket diapers, and one diaper (that I love and want more of!) that is kind of a pocket diaper with the stuffing attached so that it's technically an AIO. And I'm always on the hunt for other great options to try because once you start, it's hard to stop!
Stay tuned, because soon I'll let you know how to handle the diaper changes themselves and the dreaded laundry...